So read a headline in the 10-12-10 Plain Dealer.  According to the Northeast Ohio Areawide Coordinating Agency, from 2007-09, Mentor had 245 car-animal crashes, an average of one insurance claim every 4.5 days.  We’re way ahead of second-place Strongsville, which had a measly 180 collisions over the same three-year period.

NOACA further reported that the stretch of Route 2 in Mentor had 78 crashes, the highest total on any route in one community.  Again, Strongsville came in  second with 52 incidents on I-71.

My own stats:  When I lived in Mentor on Melshore Drive during the 60s and 70s, I seldom to never saw a deer in a year’s time.  Then I moved to southeast Concord to a home surrounded by acres of woods and occasionally saw deer.  In 1996 I decided it really was Better in Mentor and moved back to the northern section of the city.

I was thrilled to see a couple of deer a couple of times a week.   We lived in happy coexistence.  But around 2005, I began to see several deer a couple times a day.  Over the past two years, the herds of 6-8 deer I’d been seeing grew to a steady 12-16 deer seen 2-4 times a day.

Happy coexistence is no longer possible.  As I pointed out in earlier postings, the deer are destroying the habitat of both flora and fauna in our parks and nature preserves.  Because we’ve wiped out much of their own habitat.  Because we wanted the convenience of another strip mall, another lane of highway.  Because we replaced nursery acreage with housing developments and pavement.

When I first moved to Mentor, the city was known as the Nursery Capital of the USA.  Now  we’re the Car-animal Accident Capital of Northeastern Ohio.

Sadly, it is what it is.  We are not going to wipe out the developments or tear up the highways.  We’ve created a problem that we must solve.  And I see it as a problem that won’t be resolved with a win-win solution.  Maybe not even a win-lose solution.   But I do know that the problem will be and must be solved.

*All animals causing crashes are represented in the totals, but the vast majority of the animals are deer.



  1. Bill Wickline

    I was going to suggest a safe habitat for the deer. Our town is not likely a safe habitat for these creatures anymore. I know I said this before, but I thought the deer could be rustled up in an 18 wheeler and transported to Pennsylvania, which is very rich in forestry.

  2. Bill–
    I wish that were possible. Unfortunately, there really is no place that has a paucity of deer. Much of PA is struggling to keep their own forests healthy. Parts of PA have natural help we don’t have in most of Northeastern Ohio–they’ve still got bears and predatory big cats. The biggest natural predator our deer face is the coyote. They’re capable of taking down fawns for the first week or two of their lives.

  3. Pingback: MENTOR’S DEER POPULATION: Part II THE SOLUTIONS | My Take on Today

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s